Jean-Jacques Cornish

Sisulu accuses black judges of mentally colonialising South African

Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp
Share on email
Share on facebook
Share on print

The over-achingly  ambitious Tourism Minister Lindiwe Sisulu is standing by an incendiary article she penned criticizing South Africa’s world renowned constitution and black judges.

The article is seen as an opening volley in her bid to win the presidency at the elective congress of ruling African National Congress in December.

Her early appearance over the parapet is entirely in keeping with this 58-year-old member of the iconic Sisulu family’s  desire to lead the ANC and thereby the country.

She has held no fewer than six Cabinet positions, including the defence and foreign ministry portfolios.

Her first bid for the presidency was a decade ago when she was beaten by the incumbent Jacob Zuma.

In 2017 she contested the deputy presidency where she was beaten by the David Mabuza.

Her opinion piece says apartheid was legal, as were the Jim Crow laws in the United States, colonialism and even nazism.

“So does that mean we have the rule of law?” she asks. “And whose law is it anyway?”

She asks how poverty can exist in a judicial system and under a constitution that is admired by the world.

She charges that South Africa is being “mentally colonized by black judges settled with the view and mindset of those who have dispossessed their ancestors.”

Embarrassingly, she is accused of plagiarism for using several hundred words without accreditation from a speech by former British Attorney General Dominic Grieve.

The ANC, of whom Sisulu is a member of the executive committee, has distances itself from her remarks.

The presidency calls the article recklessness of the highest order.

Minister in the Presidency Mondli Gungubele points out that  the constitution of which Sisulu is suddenly so critical was never forced upon her.

Acting Chief Justice Raymond Zondo says Sisulu’s article is an insult to judges of the Constitutional Court, the Supreme Court of Appeal and the provincial High Courts.

He strongly disagrees with his submission that the rule of law does not serve the interests of the black majority of South African.

Judges must be prepared to accept  factual criticism and analysis, says Zondo,  but none of this is contained in Sisulu’s article which is simply insulting.

Craig Watt-Pringle the chairman of the General Bar Association says the timing of Sisulu’s piece can be interpreted as an attack on the Zondo Commission into State Capture.

He says President Cyril Ramaphosa must act against a member of his cabinet who has crossed the line.

Her criticism of unspecified judges and unspecified rulings serves to undermine the judiciary and intimidate judges.

Former ANC chief whip, who served a prison sentence for fraud after being appointed to defence review committee by Sisulu accused Zondo of being a cry baby and says judges must get used to being criticized.

Sisulu says she will respond to the criticism in an appropriate forum at an appropriate time.

Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp
Share on email
Share on facebook
Share on print

Enquire about availability for radio, podcasts, reporting or opinion pieces.

Jean-Jacques Cornish is a journalist and broadcaster who has been involved in the media all his adult life.

Starting as a reporter on his hometown newspaper, he moved briefly to then Rhodesia before returning to South Africa to become a parliamentary correspondent with the South African Press Association. He was sent to London as Sapa’s London editor and also served as special correspondent to the United Nations. He joined the then Argus group in London as political correspondent.

Returning to South Africa after 12 years abroad, he was assistant editor on the Pretoria News for a decade before becoming editor of the Star and SA Times for five years.

Since 1999 he’s been an independent journalist writing and broadcasting – mainly about Africa – for Talk Radio 702 and 567 Cape
Talk, Radio France International, PressTV, Radio Live New Zealand, Business Day, Mail & Guardian, the BBC, Agence France Press,
Business in Africa, Leadership, India Today, the South African Institute for International Affairs and the Institute for Security Studies.

He has hosted current affairs talk shows on Talk Radio 702 and 567 Cape Talk. He appears as an African affairs pundit on SABC Africa and CNBC Africa.
He lectured in contemporary studies to journalism students at the Tshwane University of Technology and the University of Pretoria.

He speaks on African affairs to corporate and other audiences.
He has been officially invited as a journalist to more than 30 countries. He was the winner of the 2007 SADC award for radio journalism.

He’s been a member of the EISA team observing elections in Somaliland, Democratic Republic of Congo, Madagascar, Zimbabwe, Egypt and Tunsiai.

In October 2009 he headed a group of 39 African journalists to the 60th anniversary celebrations of the Peoples’ Republic of China.

In January 2010 he joined a rescue and paramedical team to earthquake struck Haiti.

He is immediate past president of the Alliance Francaise of Pretoria.

Jean-Jacques is a director of Giant Media. The company was given access to Nelson Mandela in his retirement years until 2009.
He is co-producer of the hour-long documentary Mandela at 90 that was broadcast on BBC in January 2009.